Skip to content
StaySTRA - logo
  • Analyzer
  • Locations
  • Sell Me Your BNB
Sign In
  • Analyzer
  • Locations
  • Sell Me Your BNB
Sign In
  1. Home
  2. Locations
  3. Wisconsin
  4. Sister Bay

Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Short-Term Rental Market Data & Investment Analysis

Sister Bay, Wisconsin Short-Term Rental Market

CMarket Score 63/100

Quick Answer: Sister Bay, Wisconsin is an active short-term rental market. average occupancy is 34%. average monthly revenue is $2,251. average daily rate is $280. the top operator is Simple Life Rentals with 109 listings. market score is 63/100 (grade C).

Avg Monthly Revenue
$2,251
↑ 8.2% YoY
34%
Occupancy
↑ 10.8% YoY
$280
Avg Daily Rate
↓ 0.4% YoY
$94
RevPAR
↑ 10.3% YoY
59.4 days avg lead time3 avg length of stay

Market Score Breakdown

Five dimensions Apivex evaluates per market.

Regulation71
Seasonality43
Investability96
Rental Demand83
Revenue Growth50

Seasonal Patterns

Monthly seasonal data for Sister Bay, Wisconsin
MonthOccupancyADRRevenue
Jan27%$228$1,804
Feb35%$227$1,887
Mar39%$220$2,241
Apr36%$230$2,064
May52%$268$2,745
Jun68%$326$5,171
Jul80%$332$6,694
Aug76%$327$6,453
Sep57%$302$4,638
Oct54%$302$4,516
Nov28%$247$2,250
Dec33%$247$2,169

Top Short-Term Rental Operators in Sister Bay

Ranked by total active listings. Useful for understanding the competitive landscape.

#OperatorListingsReviewsRating
1Simple Life Rentals1094,789★ 4.67
2Rent Door County621,953★ 4.71
3Evolve403,287★ 4.77
4DoCo Vacations386,959★ 4.93
5Northern Door Vacations22711★ 4.90

What Kind of STR Should I Buy in Sister Bay?

Revenue and pricing by property type, tier, and bedroom count.

Revenue by Bedroom Count

1 bed316
2 bed448
3 bed521
4 bed256
5 bed129

ADR by Property Tier

Entire Home$287
Luxury$437
Professionally Managed$325

Revenue by Dwelling Type

Apartment$1,423
Entire Place$2,316
House$2,540

Booking Channel Mix

Distribution of bookings across major STR platforms.

Channel mix
ChannelShare
airbnb28.7%
vrbo20.6%
both50.7%

Investment Analysis

Revenue Trend (5 yr)

ADR & Occupancy Trends (5 yr)

Run a Free Address Analysis

Skip the market averages. Get revenue projections, comp analysis, and ROI for your specific property address. Free, instant, no signup required.

Analyze My Property →
Or unlock unlimited market data with StaySTRA Pro
Sister Bay, WisconsinRev $2,251ADR $280Occ 34%Score C (63)

Analyze Sister Bay Rentals

Use our free calculator to estimate Airbnb revenue for any property in Sister Bay.

Free Sister Bay STR Calculator →

Analyze Any Property

Get instant revenue projections for any property in Sister Bay.

Try the Analyzer

Table of Contents

Loading...

Quick Facts: Sister Bay

Active STRs
205
Avg Daily Rate
$494
Occupancy Rate
71%
Population
1,170
Annual Visitors
600,000

Related Articles

  • Maryland coastal vacation rental home at dusk with warm lighting and safety features visible
    A Fire That Killed Two Sisters Is Now a Law. What Maryland STR Hosts Are Doing to Make Sure It Never Happens at Their Property. April 29, 2026
  • Door County Wisconsin vacation rental cabins along Green Bay waterfront with sailboats and cherry orchards
    Door County WI Short-Term Rental Market 2026. What StaySTRA Data Shows for the Great Lakes Most Popular Summer Destination May 24, 2026
  • Maryland State House in Annapolis with fire safety equipment symbolizing the Wiener Short-Term Rental Safety Act
    Maryland Just Set the National Standard for STR Safety. Here Is What the Law Actually Requires. April 24, 2026
  • Mountain cabin porch with notebook and coffee mug overlooking snow-capped peaks in early spring, representing STR host preparation for summer 2026
    Summer Is Already Booked. How STR Hosts Across America Are Preparing for 2026’s Peak Season April 9, 2026
  • A warm ranch-style vacation rental in Bend Oregon with Cascade Mountain views at sunset
    Desert Peak to Snow Line: The People Running Bend, Oregon’s Most-Booked Vacation Rentals April 8, 2026

Markets in Wisconsin (50)

  • Arkdale
  • Athelstane
  • Baraboo
  • Bayfield
  • Black River Falls
  • Brodhead
  • Butternut
  • Chetek
  • Cornucopia
  • Crandon
  • Cumberland
  • Eagle River
  • East Troy
  • Egg Harbor
  • Elcho
  • Elkhart Lake
  • Elkhorn
  • Fontana
  • Frederic
  • Friendship
  • Genoa City
  • Gleason
  • Grand Marsh
  • Green Bay
  • Hayward
  • Hubertus
  • Hudson
  • Kewaunee
  • La Pointe
  • La Valle
  • Lake Geneva
  • Lake Mills
  • Little Suamico
  • Lyndon Station
  • Madison
  • Manitowish Waters
  • Mauston
  • Menomonie
  • Merrillan
  • Milwaukee
  • Necedah
  • Neillsville
  • Nekoosa
  • New Lisbon
  • Ojibwa
  • Pickerel
  • Pleasant Prairie
  • Saint Germain
  • Shawano
  • Sheboygan

Top STR Markets

  • Austin, TX
  • Nashville, TN
  • Miami, FL
  • Scottsdale, AZ
  • San Diego, CA
  • Denver, CO
  • Charleston, SC
  • Savannah, GA
  • New Orleans, LA
  • Joshua Tree, CA
  • Gatlinburg, TN
  • Gulf Shores, AL
  • Destin, FL
  • Sedona, AZ
  • Park City, UT
  • South Lake Tahoe, CA
  • Kissimmee, FL
  • Pigeon Forge, TN
  • Panama City Beach, FL
  • Broken Bow, OK
  • Blue Ridge, GA
  • Mammoth Lakes, CA
  • Big Bear City, CA
  • Key West, FL
  • Asheville, NC
  • San Antonio, TX
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Las Vegas, NV
  • Orlando, FL
  • Myrtle Beach, SC
  • Branson, MO
View All Locations →

You ran the numbers. Now finance it.

Get DSCR Financing Built for STR Investors

Qualify on the property's cash flow, not your W-2. Fast closings, competitive rates, no income verification.

Check DSCR Eligibility →

Sponsored by Beeline. StaySTRA may earn a referral fee.

StaySTRA - logo

The smart way to analyze short-term rental investments. Get revenue projections, market data, and insights powered by real short-term rental market data.

Product

  • Analyzer
  • Pricing
  • Locations

Resources

  • Blog
  • STR Tools
  • STR Laws
  • Top Markets

Company

  • Sell Your BNB
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Subscribe to newsletter

Sign up to get STR insights and market data delivered to your inbox.

©2026 StaySTRA.com. All rights reserved.

Take a look at our sister companies

Neuhaus Realty Group - Austin Real Estate Broker Neuhaus Realty Group Bizzy Lizzy - Embroidered Women's Clothing Boutique Bizzy Lizzy Boutique Kendall Creek Properties - Real Estate Investment & Property Management Kendall Creek Properties
×
Get Started Now

Create your account to start analyzing properties

or
Forgot password?

Don't have an account? Sign up Already have an account? Sign in

Welcome back to StaySTRA

Analyze properties, track investments, and grow your short-term rental portfolio

Instant property analysis
Advanced STR metrics
Save & compare properties
Choose Your Plan
Stay Ahead of the Market

Join 2,500+ STR investors getting weekly insights

Weekly STR market insights
New feature announcements
Investment tips & strategies
Exclusive subscriber offers
Send Us a Message

We typically respond within 24 hours

Please sign in or create an account to send your message

Choose Your Plan

Select a plan to get started with StaySTRA

Free
$0 forever

1 property analysis per month • Basic STR metrics • Email support

Pro Monthly
$7 per month

Unlimited property analyses • Advanced STR metrics • Save & compare properties • Print reports

Best Value
Pro Annual
$59 per year Save $25

Everything in Pro Monthly • Best value - equivalent to 2 months free • Priority support