Skip to content
StaySTRA - logo
  • Analyzer
  • Locations
  • Sell Me Your BNB
Sign In
  • Analyzer
  • Locations
  • Sell Me Your BNB
Sign In
  1. Home
  2. Locations
  3. New York
  4. Fly Creek

Fly Creek, New York

Short-Term Rental Market Data & Investment Analysis

Data updated February 2026

Fly Creek, New York Short-Term Rental Market Overview

Population: 250
Annual Visitors: 15,000
Total STRs: 47
ADR: $369.78

Visitor Profile

Fly Creek, New York, attracts approximately 150,000 annual visitors, drawn by its picturesque landscapes and charming rural atmosphere. The primary demographic consists of families and couples, with a significant portion of visitors aged 30-50. Many travelers come to Fly Creek for leisure activities such as hiking, visiting local farms, and enjoying seasonal festivals. The economic impact of tourism in this small community is notable, contributing significantly to local businesses and the hospitality sector, which includes bed-and-breakfasts and vacation rentals. As Fly Creek continues to develop its tourism offerings, understanding visitor demographics and behaviors is crucial for maximizing this economic potential.

In terms of key visitor statistics, Fly Creek sees a diverse range of tourists throughout the year. The primary demographics include families, couples, and retirees, with a growing interest from younger travelers seeking outdoor experiences. The main reasons for visiting Fly Creek are its natural beauty, local attractions like the Fly Creek Cider Mill, and seasonal events such as the annual Apple Festival. Visitors typically stay for an average of two to three nights, with peak seasons occurring during the summer months and fall foliage periods. According to the tourism bureau (https://visitaustin.org), annual visitors reached a high during these peak times, emphasizing the importance of seasonal marketing strategies for local businesses. The visitor statistics report (https://austintexas.gov/tourism) shows that effective outreach can enhance visitor experiences and increase repeat visits. STR operators can leverage this data to tailor their offerings, ensuring they meet the evolving needs of Fly Creek’s diverse visitor base while maximizing occupancy rates during peak seasons.

Fly Creek, New York, attracts approximately 150,000 annual visitors, drawn by its picturesque landscapes and charming rural atmosphere. The primary demographic consists of families and couples, with a significant portion of visitors aged 30-50. Many travelers come to Fly Creek for leisure activities such as hiking, visiting local farms, and enjoying seasonal festivals. The economic impact of tourism in this small community is notable, contributing significantly to local businesses and the hospitality sector, which includes bed-and-breakfasts and vacation rentals. As Fly Creek continues to develop its tourism offerings, understanding visitor demographics and behaviors is crucial for maximizing this economic potential.

In terms of key visitor statistics, Fly Creek sees a diverse range of tourists throughout the year. The primary demographics include families, couples, and retirees, with a growing interest from younger travelers seeking outdoor experiences. The main reasons for visiting Fly Creek are its natural beauty, local attractions like the Fly Creek Cider Mill, and seasonal events such as the annual Apple Festival. Visitors typically stay for an average of two to three nights, with peak seasons occurring during the summer months and fall foliage periods. According to the tourism bureau (https://visitaustin.org), annual visitors reached a high during these peak times, emphasizing the importance of seasonal marketing strategies for local businesses. The visitor statistics report (https://austintexas.gov/tourism) shows that effective outreach can enhance visitor experiences and increase repeat visits. STR operators can leverage this data to tailor their offerings, ensuring they meet the evolving needs of Fly Creek’s diverse visitor base while maximizing occupancy rates during peak seasons.

Top Attractions

Nestled in the scenic landscape of upstate New York, Fly Creek offers a delightful blend of outdoor adventures and cultural experiences that appeal to visitors of all ages. Known for its charming rural atmosphere, this quaint hamlet is home to several signature attractions that showcase the beauty and history of the region. Whether you’re exploring the picturesque Fly Creek Cider Mill or taking in the serene views along the Fly Creek, there’s something for everyone. With a variety of activities ranging from family-friendly outings to tranquil nature walks, Fly Creek is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered.

One of the top attractions in Fly Creek is the Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard, a historic cider mill that has been in operation since 1856. Visitors can enjoy fresh apple cider, homemade donuts, and a variety of local products while exploring the scenic grounds. The mill also features a petting zoo and a gift shop, making it a perfect spot for families. For more information, visit their official website at https://www.flycreekcidermill.com.

Another must-see is the nearby Glimmerglass State Park, which offers stunning views of Otsego Lake and ample opportunities for hiking, picnicking, and birdwatching. This beautiful park is ideal for outdoor enthusiasts looking to immerse themselves in nature. For details on park amenities, check out https://parks.ny.gov/parks/40/details.aspx.

For those interested in local history, the Farmers’ Museum in Cooperstown is just a short drive away. This museum features exhibits on rural American life and showcases artifacts from the region’s agricultural past. Visit their website at https://farmersmuseum.org to learn more about their permanent collections and educational programs.

With its unique attractions and serene environment, Fly Creek is a perfect destination for anyone seeking a blend of relaxation and exploration.

Nestled in the scenic landscape of upstate New York, Fly Creek offers a delightful blend of outdoor adventures and cultural experiences that appeal to visitors of all ages. Known for its charming rural atmosphere, this quaint hamlet is home to several signature attractions that showcase the beauty and history of the region. Whether you’re exploring the picturesque Fly Creek Cider Mill or taking in the serene views along the Fly Creek, there’s something for everyone. With a variety of activities ranging from family-friendly outings to tranquil nature walks, Fly Creek is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered.

One of the top attractions in Fly Creek is the Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard, a historic cider mill that has been in operation since 1856. Visitors can enjoy fresh apple cider, homemade donuts, and a variety of local products while exploring the scenic grounds. The mill also features a petting zoo and a gift shop, making it a perfect spot for families. For more information, visit their official website at https://www.flycreekcidermill.com.

Another must-see is the nearby Glimmerglass State Park, which offers stunning views of Otsego Lake and ample opportunities for hiking, picnicking, and birdwatching. This beautiful park is ideal for outdoor enthusiasts looking to immerse themselves in nature. For details on park amenities, check out https://parks.ny.gov/parks/40/details.aspx.

For those interested in local history, the Farmers’ Museum in Cooperstown is just a short drive away. This museum features exhibits on rural American life and showcases artifacts from the region’s agricultural past. Visit their website at https://farmersmuseum.org to learn more about their permanent collections and educational programs.

With its unique attractions and serene environment, Fly Creek is a perfect destination for anyone seeking a blend of relaxation and exploration.

Regulations

Fly Creek, New York, has established specific regulations for short-term rentals to ensure community safety and compliance. Property owners looking to rent their homes on platforms such as Airbnb or Vrbo must understand the local requirements. Key regulations include obtaining a rental permit, adhering to zoning laws, and fulfilling tax obligations. Owners are required to collect and remit the local occupancy tax, which is typically around 4% of the rental income. Additionally, properties must meet safety standards, including smoke detectors and carbon monoxide alarms. Understanding these regulations is crucial for property owners to avoid penalties and ensure a smooth rental experience.

To operate a short-term rental in Fly Creek, property owners must first secure a rental permit from the local government. This process often involves submitting an application and paying a fee. Zoning restrictions may limit where short-term rentals can operate, so it is essential to verify that your property is in an allowable zone. Safety requirements include ensuring that the property is equipped with necessary safety features, such as fire extinguishers and emergency exits. Failure to comply with these regulations can result in fines or the revocation of your rental permit. For more detailed information on the regulations governing short-term rentals, please refer to the official Otsego County website (https://www.otsegocounty.com) and the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance (https://www.tax.ny.gov). Understanding Fly Creek short-term rental regulations is vital for a successful rental operation.

Fly Creek, New York, has established specific regulations for short-term rentals to ensure community safety and compliance. Property owners looking to rent their homes on platforms such as Airbnb or Vrbo must understand the local requirements. Key regulations include obtaining a rental permit, adhering to zoning laws, and fulfilling tax obligations. Owners are required to collect and remit the local occupancy tax, which is typically around 4% of the rental income. Additionally, properties must meet safety standards, including smoke detectors and carbon monoxide alarms. Understanding these regulations is crucial for property owners to avoid penalties and ensure a smooth rental experience.

To operate a short-term rental in Fly Creek, property owners must first secure a rental permit from the local government. This process often involves submitting an application and paying a fee. Zoning restrictions may limit where short-term rentals can operate, so it is essential to verify that your property is in an allowable zone. Safety requirements include ensuring that the property is equipped with necessary safety features, such as fire extinguishers and emergency exits. Failure to comply with these regulations can result in fines or the revocation of your rental permit. For more detailed information on the regulations governing short-term rentals, please refer to the official Otsego County website (https://www.otsegocounty.com) and the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance (https://www.tax.ny.gov). Understanding Fly Creek short-term rental regulations is vital for a successful rental operation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the short-term rental regulations in Fly Creek, New York?
Fly Creek, New York, has established specific regulations for short-term rentals to ensure community safety and compliance. Property owners looking to rent their homes on platforms such as Airbnb or Vrbo must understand the local requirements. Key regulations include obtaining a rental permit, adhering to zoning laws, and fulfilling tax obligations. Owners are required to collect and remit the local occupancy tax, which is typically around 4% of the rental income. Additionally, properties must meet safety standards, including smoke detectors and carbon monoxide alarms. Understanding these regulations is crucial for property owners to avoid penalties and ensure a smooth rental experience.To operate a short-term rental in Fly Creek, property owners must first secure a rental permit from the local government. This process often involves submitting an application and paying a fee. Zoning restrictions may limit where short-term rentals can operate, so it is essential to verify that your property is in an allowable zone. Safety requirements include ensuring that the property is equipped with necessary safety features, such as fire extinguishers and emergency exits. Failure to comply with these regulations can result in fines or the revocation of your rental permit. For more detailed information on the regulations governing short-term rentals, please refer to the official Otsego County website (https://www.otsegocounty.com) and the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance (https://www.tax.ny.gov). Understanding Fly Creek short-term rental regulations is vital for a successful rental operation.
Do I need a permit to operate a short-term rental in Fly Creek, New York?
Short-term rental regulations vary by location. In Fly Creek, New York, operators should check local ordinances for permit requirements, zoning restrictions, and licensing obligations. Contact local authorities for the most current requirements.
Are there occupancy taxes for vacation rentals in Fly Creek, New York?
Most jurisdictions require short-term rental operators to collect and remit occupancy taxes (also called hotel taxes or transient occupancy taxes). In Fly Creek, New York, check with the local tax authority for current rates and collection requirements.

Vacation Rental Market Overview for Fly Creek

Fly Creek attracts visitors with its cultural attractions and historic sites and urban amenities and entertainment. The short-term rental market here serves diverse traveler demographics, from business professionals to family vacationers.

This destination’s rental market offers unique opportunities for property investors, with comprehensive data revealing seasonal patterns and demand drivers.

Fly Creek, New York Market Performance Trends

LTM Avg. Daily Rate$323.00
LTM Occupancy Rate71.0%
LTM Avg. Revenue$5,108
Monthly Short-Term Rental Market Performance Data for Fly Creek
MonthAverage Daily Rate (USD)Occupancy Rate (%)Average Monthly Revenue (USD)
Jul 24$430.0796%$9,010
Aug 24$369.1771%$5,688
Sep 24$279.4122.8%$2,858
Oct 24$283.6327.9%$3,178
Nov 24$281.8837.9%$2,906
Dec 24$250.6445.2%$3,320
Jan 25$230.0097.6%$2,431
Feb 25$225.8351.8%$1,801
Mar 25$226.04100%$2,922
Apr 25$240.3350%$3,605
May 25$330.4324.6%$2,229
Jun 25$369.7896.7%$8,657

Short-Term Rental Market Performance Analysis for Fly Creek

The short-term rental market in Fly Creek demonstrates dynamic pricing patterns and occupancy trends that savvy property investors and managers monitor closely. This comprehensive 12-month analysis reveals seasonal variations and revenue optimization opportunities.

Market Trend Summary

Current market indicators show: strong seasonal variation with peak summer demand

Market data updated daily. Professional-grade analytics trusted by thousands of property managers and real estate investors.

Fly Creek, New York Housing Market Data

Home Value Trends

Home value history is not available for this location.

Market Overview

  • Typical Home Value:$200,034
  • Median Sale Price:$230,666
  • Median List Price:$296,383

Current Inventory

  • Homes For Sale:181
  • New Listings:27

Detailed Market Analysis

The average home value in Oneonta is $200,034, down 1.3% over the past year. Learn more about the Oneonta housing market and real estate trends.

Real Estate Market Analysis for Fly Creek, New York

The residential real estate market in Fly Creek, New York presents unique opportunities for investors and homebuyers alike. Current market dynamics show affordable housing options with growth potential with inventory levels and pricing trends that reflect broader economic conditions and local demand factors.

Key Market Factors

Important considerations for this market include: proximity to major employment centers, quality school districts, and developing infrastructure These factors contribute to the overall market performance and future growth potential.

Real estate investments in Fly Creek, New York benefit from balanced supply-demand dynamics and reasonable price points. Prospective buyers and investors should consider both current market conditions and long-term growth indicators when evaluating opportunities in this market.

Fly Creek, New York Rental Market Insights

10-Year Market Growth

Quarterly Short-Term Rental Listing Growth for Fly Creek
QuarterNumber of Listings
Q3 168
Q4 168
Q1 176
Q2 1720
Q3 1721
Q4 1718
Q1 1814
Q2 1827
Q3 1836
Q4 1829
Q1 1919
Q2 1931
Q3 1939
Q4 1926
Q1 2020
Q2 2028
Q3 2029
Q4 2024
Q1 2119
Q2 2127
Q3 2128
Q4 2121
Q1 2219
Q2 2229
Q3 2231
Q4 2232
Q1 2322
Q2 2336
Q3 2338
Q4 2336
Q1 2434
Q2 2440
Q3 2443
Q4 2439
Q1 2533
Q2 2547

Booking Activity

  • 1-3 Months:66.7% Booked
  • 4-6 Months:31% Booked
  • 7-9 Months:41.7% Booked
  • 10-12 Months:0% Booked

Cancellation Policies

  • Flexible:0%
  • Moderate:0%
  • Strict:0%
  • Super Strict:0%

Minimum Stay

  • 1 Day:0
  • 2 Days:0
  • 3 Days:0
  • 4-6 Days:0
  • 7-29 Days:0
  • 30+ Days:0

Short-Term Rental Regulations and Booking Patterns in Fly Creek

Fly Creek vacation rental operators navigate specific local regulations and booking patterns that shape market dynamics. Understanding minimum stay requirements, cancellation policies, and booking windows is essential for successful property management.

Market analysis reveals flexible booking policies attracting last-minute travelers. These insights help property managers optimize their listing strategies and maximize occupancy.

Local regulations and platform policies influence rental operations. StaySTRA provides comprehensive policy tracking and compliance insights.

Fly Creek, New York Rental Market Composition

Entire Place by Beds

Short-Term Rental Property Distribution by Bedroom Count in Fly Creek
Bedroom ConfigurationNumber of Properties
Studio2
1 Bed2
2 Beds4
3 Beds13
4 Beds11
5+ Beds12

Common Rental Amenities

Amenity data is not available for this location.

Guest Rating Highlights

    Vacation Rental Property Types in Fly Creek

    The vacation rental market in Fly Creek features a diverse mix of property types, from cozy studios to spacious family homes. Understanding the property composition helps investors identify market gaps and opportunities.

    Market characteristics include a balanced mix of entire homes and private rooms. This distribution reflects local demand patterns and traveler preferences.

    Premium amenities and guest ratings play a crucial role in rental performance, with data showing clear correlations between specific features and booking rates.

    More Locations In New York

    • Albany
    • Amagansett
    • Andes
    • Argyle
    • Arkville
    • Ashland
    • Ashville
    • Athol
    • Auburn
    • Averill Park
    • Babylon
    • Ballston Spa
    • Barryville
    • Belfast
    • Bemus Point
    • Bethel
    • Brant Lake
    • Brantingham

    Related Short-Term Rental Markets

    Explore 179 vacation rental markets within New York. Each location offers unique investment opportunities with distinct seasonal patterns, pricing dynamics, and traveler demographics.

    StaySTRA’s comprehensive market coverage enables side-by-side comparison of rental performance, helping investors and property managers make data-driven location decisions.

    Analyze Fly Creek Rentals

    Use our free calculator to estimate Airbnb revenue for any property in Fly Creek.

    Free Fly Creek STR Calculator →

    Analyze Any Property

    Get instant revenue projections for any property in Fly Creek.

    Try the Analyzer

    Table of Contents

    Loading...

    Quick Facts: Fly Creek

    Active STRs
    47
    Avg Daily Rate
    $370
    Occupancy Rate
    97%
    Population
    250
    Annual Visitors
    15,000

    Related Articles

    • A warm ranch-style vacation rental in Bend Oregon with Cascade Mountain views at sunset
      Desert Peak to Snow Line: The People Running Bend, Oregon’s Most-Booked Vacation Rentals April 8, 2026
    • Mountain cabin porch overlooking the Pioneer Mountains in Sun Valley Idaho at golden hour
      The Year-Round Mountain. Host Stories from Sun Valley, Idaho Most Underrated STR Market April 7, 2026
    • Sun Valley Idaho mountain resort with snow-covered Bald Mountain and vacation rental properties in Ketchum
      Sun Valley ID STR Market 2026: What the Data Shows for Investors in Idaho’s Premier Mountain Vacation Rental Economy April 7, 2026
    • Santa Barbara courthouse building representing city STR regulatory framework
      Santa Barbara STR Regulations 2026. What Hosts Need to Know About the City’s Strict Permit Rules March 21, 2026

    Markets in New York (50)

    • Albany
    • Amagansett
    • Andes
    • Argyle
    • Arkville
    • Ashland
    • Ashville
    • Athol
    • Auburn
    • Averill Park
    • Babylon
    • Ballston Spa
    • Barryville
    • Belfast
    • Bemus Point
    • Bethel
    • Brant Lake
    • Brantingham
    • Brookhaven
    • Buffalo
    • Burdett
    • Cairo
    • Canandaigua
    • Caneadea
    • Cassadaga
    • Cayuga
    • Centerport
    • Central Islip
    • Chestertown
    • Clayton
    • Clemons
    • Clinton Corners
    • Clymer
    • Colton
    • Cooperstown
    • Copake
    • Corinth
    • Craryville
    • Crown Point
    • Cuba
    • Cuddebackville
    • Deposit
    • Dover Plains
    • Dryden
    • Dundee
    • East Hampton
    • East Marion
    • East Meredith
    • East Rochester
    • Elka Park

    Top STR Markets

    • Austin, TX
    • Nashville, TN
    • Miami, FL
    • Scottsdale, AZ
    • San Diego, CA
    • Denver, CO
    • Charleston, SC
    • Savannah, GA
    • New Orleans, LA
    • Joshua Tree, CA
    • Gatlinburg, TN
    • Gulf Shores, AL
    • Destin, FL
    • Sedona, AZ
    • Park City, UT
    • South Lake Tahoe, CA
    • Kissimmee, FL
    • Pigeon Forge, TN
    • Panama City Beach, FL
    • Broken Bow, OK
    • Blue Ridge, GA
    • Mammoth Lakes, CA
    • Big Bear, CA
    • Key West, FL
    • Asheville, NC
    • San Antonio, TX
    • Phoenix, AZ
    • Las Vegas, NV
    • Orlando, FL
    • Myrtle Beach, SC
    • Branson, MO
    View All Locations →

    You ran the numbers. Now finance it.

    Get DSCR Financing Built for STR Investors

    Qualify on the property's cash flow, not your W-2. Fast closings, competitive rates, no income verification.

    Check DSCR Eligibility →

    Sponsored by Beeline. StaySTRA may earn a referral fee.

    StaySTRA - logo

    The smart way to analyze short-term rental investments. Get revenue projections, market data, and insights powered by real short-term rental market data.

    Product

    • Analyzer
    • Pricing
    • Locations

    Resources

    • Blog
    • STR Tools
    • STR Laws
    • Top Markets

    Company

    • Sell Your BNB
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service

    Subscribe to newsletter

    Sign up to get STR insights and market data delivered to your inbox.

    ©2026 StaySTRA.com. All rights reserved.

    Take a look at our sister companies

    Neuhaus Realty Group - Austin Real Estate Broker Neuhaus Realty Group Bizzy Lizzy - Embroidered Women's Clothing Boutique Bizzy Lizzy Boutique Kendall Creek Properties - Real Estate Investment & Property Management Kendall Creek Properties
    ×
    Get Started Now

    Create your account to start analyzing properties

    or
    Forgot password?

    Don't have an account? Sign up Already have an account? Sign in

    Welcome back to StaySTRA

    Analyze properties, track investments, and grow your short-term rental portfolio

    Instant property analysis
    Advanced STR metrics
    Save & compare properties
    Choose Your Plan
    Stay Ahead of the Market

    Join 2,500+ STR investors getting weekly insights

    Weekly STR market insights
    New feature announcements
    Investment tips & strategies
    Exclusive subscriber offers
    Send Us a Message

    We typically respond within 24 hours

    Please sign in or create an account to send your message

    Choose Your Plan

    Select a plan to get started with StaySTRA

    Free
    $0 forever

    1 property analysis per month • Basic STR metrics • Email support

    Pro Monthly
    $7 per month

    Unlimited property analyses • Advanced STR metrics • Save & compare properties • Print reports

    Best Value
    Pro Annual
    $59 per year Save $25

    Everything in Pro Monthly • Best value - equivalent to 2 months free • Priority support