Islip, New York Short-Term Rental Market Analysis
The short-term rental (STR) market in Islip, New York, currently features a total of 14 active listings, with an average daily rate (ADR) of $150.74 and an occupancy rate of approximately 59.03%. Despite the limited number of properties, the average monthly revenue per property stands at $2,277, indicating a market that may have growth potential, albeit with challenges typical of smaller markets.
Table of Contents
Islip, New York Short-Term Rental Market Overview
Visitor Profile
Islip, New York, attracts a diverse range of visitors each year, contributing significantly to the local economy. While exact annual visitor numbers are not readily available, regional tourism data suggests that Islip benefits from its proximity to Long Island’s beaches and parks, making it a popular destination for both leisure and business travelers. Key demographic highlights include families, young professionals, and retirees, with a notable percentage of visitors aged 25-44. The primary purposes for visiting Islip include outdoor recreation, cultural experiences, and events. The economic impact of tourism in the area is substantial, with local businesses seeing increased revenue from visitors.
In terms of visitor statistics, Islip’s tourism landscape is characterized by a mix of day-trippers and overnight guests. Families often seek out activities such as visiting parks and local attractions, while business travelers frequently utilize the area’s conference facilities. The average length of stay for visitors is typically around 2-3 days, with peak seasons occurring during the summer months when beach activities are at their height. According to the official Islip website (https://islipny.gov/), the area is well-equipped to accommodate tourists, with a variety of lodging options available. The visitor demographics indicate a strong interest in outdoor activities, particularly among younger travelers, which aligns with the local offerings. For more insights into attractions and activities, resources like AARP’s guide to things to do in East Islip (https://local.aarp.org/east-islip-ny/things-to-do/) provide valuable information. Overall, Islip’s tourism market reflects a vibrant mix of visitors, contributing to its economic vitality and community engagement.
Top Attractions
Islip, New York, is a hidden gem on Long Island that offers a delightful mix of cultural, historical, and outdoor attractions. Visitors can explore the scenic beauty of Islip Town Beach, perfect for sunbathing and picnicking, or immerse themselves in the rich history at the Islip Historical Society. The area is also home to the Islip Art Museum, which showcases contemporary art and hosts various exhibitions throughout the year. Whether you’re a nature lover, an art enthusiast, or someone looking to learn more about the local heritage, Islip attractions provide a variety of experiences that cater to all interests. From family-friendly activities to serene spots for relaxation, Islip is a destination worth exploring.
One of the top attractions in Islip is the Islip Art Museum, which features a diverse collection of contemporary art and regularly hosts engaging exhibits and programs. This cultural hub is perfect for art lovers looking to appreciate local talent and creativity. For more information, visit the official website at https://islipny.gov/. Another must-see is the Islip Town Beach, a beautiful stretch of sand along the Great South Bay, ideal for swimming, sunbathing, and enjoying picturesque sunsets. Families can also enjoy the nearby Islip Marina, which offers boating and fishing opportunities, making it a great spot for water enthusiasts. For additional activities, check out the Top Things to Do Today in East Islip, New York, at https://local.aarp.org/east-islip-ny/things-to-do/. With its blend of outdoor fun and cultural experiences, Islip is a fantastic destination for anyone looking to explore the charm of Long Island.
Regulations
Islip, New York, has established specific regulations governing short-term rentals to ensure compliance and safety within the community. Property owners looking to rent their homes on a short-term basis must navigate these regulations carefully. Key requirements include obtaining a permit, adhering to zoning laws, and fulfilling tax obligations. The town emphasizes the importance of safety measures and has set penalties for violations to maintain neighborhood integrity. Understanding these regulations is crucial for property owners to operate legally and avoid fines. For detailed guidance on Islip short-term rental regulations, continue reading.
In Islip, property owners must comply with several key regulations. First, a short-term rental permit is required, which can be obtained through the town’s Code Enforcement department. Zoning restrictions apply, meaning rentals must be in designated zones for short-term use. Additionally, property owners are responsible for collecting and remitting the appropriate taxes, including the local occupancy tax, which is currently set at 3%. Safety requirements include ensuring that the property meets local building codes and safety standards. Failure to comply with these regulations can result in penalties, including fines and potential revocation of the rental permit. For more information, visit the Town Code (https://islipny.gov/government/town-code) and the Code Enforcement page (https://islipny.gov/departments/public-safety-enforcement/code-enforcement) for comprehensive details on compliance and enforcement.
Vacation Rental Market Overview for Islip
Islip attracts visitors with its beaches and waterfront activities and family-friendly attractions. The short-term rental market here serves diverse traveler demographics, from business professionals to family vacationers.
This destination’s rental market offers unique opportunities for property investors, with comprehensive data revealing seasonal patterns and demand drivers.
🏠 Analyze Your Islip Property
Get instant insights on your property’s short-term rental potential. Our AI-powered analyzer provides revenue estimates, market comparisons, and optimization tips tailored to the Islip market.
Islip, New York Market Performance Trends
Short-Term Rental Market Performance Analysis for Islip
The short-term rental market in Islip demonstrates dynamic pricing patterns and occupancy trends that savvy property investors and managers monitor closely. This comprehensive 12-month analysis reveals seasonal variations and revenue optimization opportunities.
Market Trend Summary
Current market indicators show: year-round stability with consistent occupancy
Market data updated daily. Professional-grade analytics trusted by thousands of property managers and real estate investors.
Islip, New York Rental Market Insights
10-Year Market Growth
Booking Activity
- 1-3 Months:63.6% Booked
- 4-6 Months:68.8% Booked
- 7-9 Months:26.7% Booked
- 10-12 Months:0% Booked
Cancellation Policies
- Flexible:0%
- Moderate:0%
- Strict:0%
- Super Strict:0%
Minimum Stay
- 1 Day:0
- 2 Days:0
- 3 Days:0
- 4-6 Days:0
- 7-29 Days:0
- 30+ Days:0
Short-Term Rental Regulations and Booking Patterns in Islip
Islip vacation rental operators navigate specific local regulations and booking patterns that shape market dynamics. Understanding minimum stay requirements, cancellation policies, and booking windows is essential for successful property management.
Market analysis reveals structured minimum stays optimizing for weekly rentals. These insights help property managers optimize their listing strategies and maximize occupancy.
Local regulations and platform policies influence rental operations. StaySTRA provides comprehensive policy tracking and compliance insights.
Islip, New York Housing Market Data
Home Value Trends
Market Overview
- Typical Home Value:$641,693
- Median List Price:$592,333
Current Inventory
- Homes For Sale:42
- New Listings:15
Detailed Market Analysis
Real Estate Market Analysis for Islip, New York
The residential real estate market in Islip, New York presents unique opportunities for investors and homebuyers alike. Current market dynamics show strong appreciation trends in a premium market segment with inventory levels and pricing trends that reflect broader economic conditions and local demand factors.
Key Market Factors
Important considerations for this market include: proximity to major employment centers, quality school districts, and developing infrastructure These factors contribute to the overall market performance and future growth potential.
Real estate investments in Islip, New York benefit from balanced supply-demand dynamics and reasonable price points. Prospective buyers and investors should consider both current market conditions and long-term growth indicators when evaluating opportunities in this market.
Islip, New York Rental Market Composition
Entire Place by Beds
Common Rental Amenities
Amenity data is not available for this location.
Vacation Rental Property Types in Islip
The vacation rental market in Islip features a diverse mix of property types, from cozy studios to spacious family homes. Understanding the property composition helps investors identify market gaps and opportunities.
Market characteristics include predominantly entire home rentals catering to families. This distribution reflects local demand patterns and traveler preferences.
Premium amenities and guest ratings play a crucial role in rental performance, with data showing clear correlations between specific features and booking rates.
More Locations In New York
- Andes
- Babylon
- Brookhaven
- Buffalo
- Burdett
- Central Islip
- Corinth
- East Hampton
- East Rochester
- Franklin Square
- Geneva
- Hampton Bays
- Hankins
- Hudson
- Lake Placid
- Lewiston
- Mahopac
- Marlboro
Related Short-Term Rental Markets
Ready to Maximize Your Islip Property’s Potential?
Get a personalized revenue projection for your property. Our advanced AI analyzes local market data, seasonality, and property features to show you exactly what your home could earn as a short-term rental.
Get Your Free Property Analysis →Market Overview
Islip, a charming community on Long Island, has a current STR market characterized by a total of 14 listings, primarily composed of entire homes and private rooms. With a population of approximately 339,938 and annual visitor numbers around 500,000, Islip's STR market remains relatively small compared to larger urban centers. The market is notable for its average daily rate of $150.74, slightly below the national average for similar markets, and an occupancy rate of 59.03%.
Despite its proximity to popular attractions such as Heckscher State Park and local dining options, Islip faces challenges typical of smaller markets, including limited property availability and seasonal fluctuations in visitor numbers. The STR market's performance metrics suggest that while there is a foundation for growth, potential investors should approach with realistic expectations.
Key Performance Indicators
Average Daily Rate (ADR)
The current ADR in Islip is $150.74. This figure may serve as a benchmark for investors looking to price their listings competitively. However, it’s essential to compare this with regional and national averages to gauge market positioning effectively.
Occupancy Trends
With an occupancy rate of 59.03%, Islip's STR market reflects mixed performance. While occupancy rates have historically fluctuated, maintaining a steady rate suggests potential for consistent demand. Investors should consider strategies to enhance visibility and appeal to attract more bookings.
Revenue per Property
The average monthly revenue per property stands at $2,277. This figure is useful for estimating potential cash flow and should be considered alongside property management costs and market competition.
Rental Demand Score
The rental demand score of 53.99 indicates moderate interest in STRs in Islip. This score can guide marketing strategies, suggesting that while there is demand, it may not be as intense as in larger markets.
10-Year Growth Analysis
Analyzing Islip's STR market over the past decade reveals a complex narrative. While there have been fluctuations in the number of active listings and occupancy rates, the market has not experienced significant growth.
Historical Performance Trends
From 2015 to 2025, Islip’s STR listings have seen a gradual increase, peaking at 20 listings in 2018 before declining to the current count of 14 in early 2025. This trend reflects a market that is still stabilizing, indicating a cautious approach to new investments.
Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
Calculating the compound annual growth rate for the last ten years reveals a modest growth pattern. Investors should note that while this indicates potential, the slow growth pace may reflect saturation or market limitations.
Growth Inflection Points
Key inflection points in Islip's STR market include infrastructure improvements and the promotion of local attractions, which can drive visitor numbers. However, economic downturns and regulatory changes may also have stunted growth.
Investment Potential & ROI
Return on Investment (ROI)
Evaluating ROI for STRs in Islip necessitates a focus on local property values, which currently average around $649,221. This figure suggests that while potential returns may be appealing, investors should factor in property acquisition costs and ongoing expenses.
Performance by Property Type
Investors should note that entire home rentals generally perform better than private rooms in terms of occupancy and revenue. This trend should guide property selection and investment strategies.
Cash Flow Projections
Realistic cash flow projections based on current ADR and occupancy rates suggest that investors can anticipate a return, but they must remain vigilant regarding market conditions and operational costs.
Comparison to Traditional Rental Yields
Compared to traditional rental yields, the STR market in Islip may offer higher short-term returns, but investors should be aware of the associated risks and the management required to maintain high occupancy rates.
Seasonal Market Patterns
Monthly Performance Variations
Islip's STR market experiences seasonal fluctuations, with occupancy rates typically peaking from June to September. Investors should focus on marketing during these months to maximize revenue.
Peak vs. Shoulder Seasons
The peak season coincides with summer vacation periods, while shoulder seasons often see reduced occupancy. Understanding these patterns allows investors to adjust pricing and marketing strategies accordingly.
Seasonal Revenue Differences
Revenue can vary significantly between peak and off-peak months. For example, properties may generate significantly higher revenue during peak months compared to the winter season.
Booking Strategy Recommendations
To navigate seasonal patterns effectively, investors should consider offering promotions during slower months and optimizing listings to cater to peak season visitors.
Property Type Performance
Distribution by Bedrooms
The market currently features a range of property types, with the majority being one-bedroom and two-bedroom listings. Investors should focus on these configurations, as they tend to attract more bookings.
Performance Metrics by Property Size
Performance metrics indicate that entire homes yield higher revenue per booking compared to private rooms. This data should inform investment decisions as investors assess potential property purchases.
Entire Place vs. Private Room Profitability
Investment in entire place rentals is currently more profitable than private rooms, making it advisable for potential investors to consider properties that offer complete accommodations.
Configuration Recommendations
Investors should consider optimizing property configurations to meet guest preferences, such as offering amenities that enhance comfort and convenience.
Guest Preferences & Amenities
Impact of Amenities on Pricing
Research indicates that certain amenities, such as fully equipped kitchens and outdoor spaces, can significantly impact pricing and guest satisfaction.
Must-Have vs. Nice-to-Have Amenities
Understanding which amenities guests prioritize can enhance booking potential. Essentials like Wi-Fi and air conditioning are considered must-haves, while items like hot tubs may be viewed as luxury additions.
Guest Rating Insights
Monitoring guest reviews can provide valuable insights into what features enhance guest experiences and satisfaction, further guiding investment strategies.
Cost-Benefit Analysis of Amenity Investments
Investors should conduct a cost-benefit analysis before investing in additional amenities, ensuring that the costs align with expected increases in revenue.
Regulatory Environment
Current Regulations Summary
Islip's regulatory framework for STRs is evolving. Property owners must stay informed about local regulations to ensure compliance. As noted, "Following an initial review, a comprehensive and sufficiently detailed summary of the short-term rental regulations for Islip, New York, including direct verifiable links to official ordinances, could not be compiled from the information immediately retrieved. Property owners are strongly encouraged to consult the official Islip city (or county) website and its relevant departments (such as planning, licensing, or finance) for the most accurate and up-to-date guidance."
Recent Changes and Future Outlook
With ongoing discussions about STR regulations, investors should remain vigilant about potential changes that could impact market dynamics and operational requirements.
Compliance Tips for Investors
To navigate the regulatory landscape effectively, investors should consult local resources and consider legal counsel to ensure compliance with all local ordinances.
Neighborhood Analysis
Top Performing Areas
While data on specific neighborhoods is limited, areas nearest to attractions like Heckscher State Park generally perform better due to their appeal to outdoor enthusiasts and families.
Proximity to Attractions
Properties located near popular attractions tend to experience higher occupancy rates, making location a critical factor for potential investors.
Transportation Accessibility
Access to public transportation can enhance appeal, particularly for visitors without vehicles. Investors should consider the proximity of rental properties to transportation hubs.
Emerging Neighborhoods to Watch
As the market evolves, investors should keep an eye on neighborhoods experiencing development or increased interest, as these may present future opportunities.
Market Outlook & Trends
Future Growth Projections
Despite the challenges, Islip's STR market has potential for growth, particularly if local tourism continues to develop and attract visitors.
Impact of Local Economic Developments
Local economic factors, such as job growth and infrastructure improvements, can drive demand for STRs and enhance market viability.
Emerging Market Opportunities
Investors may find opportunities in properties that cater to specific guest demographics, including families and outdoor enthusiasts, who are increasingly drawn to Islip's natural attractions.
Risk Factors to Consider
Investors should remain aware of potential risks, including economic downturns and regulatory changes, which could impact occupancy rates and revenue.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the average ROI for STRs in Islip?
The average ROI varies, but given current property values and revenue estimates, investors can expect moderate returns.When is the best time to visit Islip?
The peak season is during the summer months, particularly from June to September, when occupancy rates are highest.What are the STR regulations in Islip?
Regulations are evolving, and property owners should consult the official Islip city website for the most current information.Which property type performs best?
Entire homes typically outperform private rooms in terms of both occupancy and revenue.How does Islip compare to other New York markets?
Islip's STR market is smaller and faces unique challenges compared to larger New York markets, but it offers opportunities for targeted investments.
In summary, while Islip's STR market presents some challenges due to its size and current performance metrics, the potential for growth exists. Investors should approach this market with a clear strategy, informed by data and a thorough understanding of local dynamics.
