September Is a Different Animal: Loretta’s Guide to the Fall Shoulder Season and the Guests Who Come With It

Here is the thing about September that the crying hosts never figure out: the guests who book in September are the ones who should have been booking all along.

Every summer I hear from hosts who spent July and August fielding noise complaints, chasing security deposits, and replacing things that had no business being broken. The bachelor parties. The mystery stains. The group of twelve who swore they were just four. And then Labor Day weekend hits, the calendar clears out, and those same hosts sit at their kitchen tables staring at a slow September and deciding that the shoulder season is the problem.

Sugar, the shoulder season is not the problem. The summer guests were the problem. September is the solution.

Who Is the September Guest, and Why I Am Fond of Them

I have watched short-term rental guests for a long time. The September guest is a different breed.

They are not here for a party. They are not here to see how many people fit in a hot tub. They are here because they found a beautiful property at a reasonable rate, and they want to read a book on your porch, sleep in a real bed, and not think about their office for four days.

September is the month of the couple. The quiet anniversary trip. The two friends who have been saying they would take a fall girls’ trip since the pandemic and finally actually did it. The remote worker who realized they can close their laptop anywhere and picked somewhere pretty. These guests book three to five nights on average, they respect check-out times, and they write the kind of reviews that make you want to keep doing this.

October adds a whole new category: the foliage hunter. If you are in a mountain market, New England, the Smokies, the Blue Ridge, the Hudson Valley, or anywhere trees do their autumn business in visible fashion, you already know what I mean. These guests plan weeks in advance, they are obsessed with peak color timing, and they will book a full week without flinching at the rate. They are not price-sensitive. They are season-sensitive. Get your calendar set up, your photos updated with fall imagery, and your listing titles tweaked before they start searching.

The work-from-anywhere crowd also peaks in fall. The calendar clears, rates feel more reasonable, and your mountain cabin or coastal cottage becomes the perfect remote office for three weeks. These guests fill the weekday gaps that nobody touched in August when everyone wanted weekends.

What Summer Did to Your Property

Before you think about fall guests, you have to reckon with what your last guests left behind.

Summer is hard on short-term rental properties. High volume, high turnover, guests using everything twice as enthusiastically as they would at home. Your property is tired.

HVAC filters should have been changed months ago and probably were not. Outdoor furniture baking since June needs honest assessment. A wobbly chair that did not matter in July becomes a liability in October when your guests are sitting in it with a glass of wine watching the leaves. Linens that survived summer at a threadbare level need to be retired now, not after a guest leaves a review about it.

Walk the property like a first-time guest. Open the cabinets, check the oven, smell every room. Hosts who skip the deep clean and just do the regular turnover between summer and fall often discover in late September that something has been quietly wrong for weeks. By then they have a review that says so.

Restock what summer ate. Check the welcome book. Did that restaurant close? Update everything before guests arrive who chose your property because your listing looked current.

The Pricing Mistake That Makes Me Tired

Here is what I see every September without fail: hosts who survived a busy summer, watched their October calendar show some open nights, and immediately dropped their rates fifteen to twenty percent because they got scared.

Bless their hearts. They then wonder why October looks so much worse than they hoped.

Panic pricing is a trap. When you drop rates dramatically in early September, you do not attract more of the quality October guests. You attract the guests who were always going to book but now get to book cheaper. You have not expanded your market. You have subsidized the same market. Meanwhile, the foliage hunters and anniversary couples who were planning to book your property at your normal rate now see an artificially low price and wonder if something is wrong, or they book now instead of October and you end up with September occupancy that still does not make you happy.

What actually works: hold your rates into September longer than feels comfortable. Then use a structured minimum stay strategy to shape who books. A three-night minimum for shoulder season weekends filters out the one-night booking that fills a slot but leaves you with a turnover cost and no room to breathe. Longer minimum stays in the shoulder season are not a deterrent for the guests you want. Those guests are planning a real trip, and three nights feels like nothing to them.

If you need to move specific dates, use targeted discounts for returning guests rather than a wholesale rate drop. Hosts who maintain rate discipline through September and into early October consistently close the RevPAR gap more effectively than hosts who panic-drop. The full seasonal market analysis covers how fall patterns differ by market type.

Why October Is the Best-Kept Secret in STR Hosting

October gets a bad reputation from hosts who do not understand what it actually is.

Yes, occupancy is lower than July. That is a fact and it is not going to change. But in mountain markets especially, October ADR holds remarkably well even as booking volume softens. You are booking fewer nights, but you are booking them at rates that stay close to summer levels, which means your revenue picture is better than the calendar looks.

This is a function of who is booking. The October foliage guest, the anniversary traveler, the remote worker who wants a month in the mountains: these guests are not bargain hunters. They found your property and they want it. They are choosing you because of your porch, your views, your linens, or whatever makes your property worth booking. October is the month you lean into those strengths, not apologize for them by cutting your price.

Update your listing photos to include fall imagery if you have it. If you do not have fall photos, get them this October and you will have them every year after. Add foliage-related language to your listing description if it applies. Mention proximity to hiking trails, scenic drives, apple orchards, whatever your area has going for it in fall. Guests searching for fall experiences do specific searches, and your listing needs to show up in them.

If work-from-anywhere guests are realistic for your market, add a line or two about your workspace setup. Good WiFi speed, a proper desk, quiet mornings, strong cell service. These details are the reason a remote worker picks your property over a competitor for a weeks-long stay.

For new hosts wondering what the first slow season really looks like from the inside, this piece on the first off-season covers what hosts and investors typically discover when the summer crowds leave.

Loretta’s Bottom Line

The hosts who are anxious about September and October right now are, in my experience, the same hosts who were complaining in July about their party guests and their security deposit disputes and their inexplicable furniture damage.

The shoulder season does not create problems. It reveals them.

If your summer business was built on discount rates, high volume, no guest screening, and no minimum stays, then yes, September is going to feel like a cliff. But if you ran a tight operation this summer (good rates, clear house rules, the right guests for your property), then fall is not a problem. Fall is a reward. Quieter guests, longer stays, lower turnover costs, and an October ADR that probably surprises you if you check it honestly.

Reset the property. Hold your rates. Update your listing for fall travelers. Extend your minimum stays. Stop reading the forums full of people crying about occupancy. Those people were crying in July too. They will be crying in December. Do not let them talk you into managing your business by their feelings.

September is a different animal than July. Honey, it is a better one.

StaySTRA data and content are updated regularly. Market conditions change. Verify current occupancy and rate data for your specific market at the StaySTRA Analyzer.

Want Loretta delivered straight to your inbox? Get the StaySTRA Insider and stay ahead of what is happening in short-term rental hosting before everyone else figures it out.