StaySTRA vs AllTheRooms: STR Analytics Comparison

StaySTRA and AllTheRooms both serve the short-term rental analytics space, but they solve fundamentally different problems. StaySTRA helps individual investors evaluate specific properties. AllTheRooms provides broad market intelligence across global rental markets. This comparison breaks down pricing, features, and which tool fits your situation.

Quick Comparison

What Is AllTheRooms?

AllTheRooms started as a vacation rental metasearch engine and evolved into a market analytics platform. In August 2025, it was acquired by Deckard Technologies, a GovTech company focused on short-term rental compliance (their flagship product is Rentalscape, a municipal STR enforcement tool). AllTheRooms CEO Will Pearson transitioned to Director of Operations at Deckard.

The platform aggregates data from Airbnb, VRBO, and Booking.com across 200+ countries. It tracks occupancy rates, average daily rates (ADR), and revenue per available room (RevPAR) at the market level. AllTheRooms holds six US patents for cross-platform listing deduplication, claiming 95.5% accuracy in matching the same property across different booking sites.

It is a market research tool, not a property investment calculator. You cannot enter a specific address and get projected returns. If you need to know how the short-term rental market in Lisbon is performing overall, AllTheRooms can tell you. If you need to know whether a specific duplex in Austin will cash flow, it cannot.

Pricing Breakdown

This is where the two tools diverge sharply. StaySTRA uses flat pricing. AllTheRooms charges per market.

StaySTRA Pricing

• Free: 3 analyses per month, full investment metrics, no account required
• Pro: $7/mo for unlimited analyses, 20+ metrics, PDF reports
• Pro Annual: $59/yr (saves $25), 30-day money-back guarantee

AllTheRooms Pricing (Per Market)

The per-market pricing adds up fast. An investor analyzing five cities on the Pro plan would pay $245/mo ($1,740/yr on annual billing). That same investor would pay $7/mo ($59/yr) with StaySTRA Pro, which includes unlimited analyses across all 2,600+ US markets.

Where AllTheRooms Wins

• Global coverage: 200+ countries and 10M+ listings. If you invest internationally or need data outside the US, AllTheRooms is one of very few options.
• Multi-platform data: Aggregates from Airbnb, VRBO, and Booking.com. Most competitors only track Airbnb. (Note: some users report VRBO integration is incomplete.)
• Historical depth: Up to 49 months of historical data on Pro plans, with records going back to 2016. Useful for spotting long-term market trends and seasonality patterns.
• Cross-platform deduplication: Six US patents for identifying the same property listed on multiple platforms. This gives cleaner supply counts and more accurate market size estimates.
• Market share analysis: See how supply and demand shift between platforms within a market over time.

Where StaySTRA Wins

• Property-level analysis: Enter any US address and get projected revenue, expenses, and returns for that specific property. AllTheRooms only provides market-level aggregates.
• Investment metrics: 20+ metrics including NOI, cap rate, DSCR, and cash-on-cash return. These are the numbers investors actually need to make purchase decisions.
• Simple, flat pricing: $7/mo for everything. No per-market fees, no surprise charges when you want to research a new city.
• No account required: Run 3 free analyses per month without signing up. AllTheRooms requires registration even for the free tier.
• PDF reports: Generate professional reports to share with partners, lenders, or your own records.
• Active product development: StaySTRA is building new features for individual investors. AllTheRooms' parent company is focused on government compliance tools (see below).

The Deckard Acquisition: What It Means

Deckard Technologies acquired AllTheRooms in August 2025. Deckard's core business is Rentalscape, a platform that helps cities and counties identify and enforce short-term rental regulations. Their customers are municipalities, not individual investors.

The AllTheRooms consumer product continues to operate, but the acquisition signals a strategic shift. Deckard likely values AllTheRooms' data aggregation and deduplication technology for compliance use cases (helping cities find unlicensed rentals) more than for consumer analytics.

This does not mean AllTheRooms will disappear tomorrow. But investors should consider whether a product whose parent company serves a completely different customer base will continue receiving meaningful feature updates for individual users. Trustpilot reviews (2.5/5 as of early 2026) cite auto-renewal friction and slow customer support, which may reflect shifting internal priorities.

Who Should Use Which Tool?

Choose AllTheRooms if:

• You invest in international markets outside the US
• You need multi-platform data (Airbnb + VRBO + Booking.com)
• You are a property manager or enterprise user tracking broad market trends across many cities
• You need deep historical data going back years for academic or institutional research

Choose StaySTRA if:

• You want to evaluate a specific property before buying
• You need investment return metrics (NOI, cap rate, DSCR, cash-on-cash)
• You invest in the US and want simple, affordable pricing
• You want to run quick analyses without creating an account
• You need exportable PDF reports for lenders or partners

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use AllTheRooms to analyze a specific property?

No. AllTheRooms provides market-level data only (occupancy rates, ADR, and RevPAR for a geographic area). It cannot project revenue, expenses, or investment returns for a specific address. StaySTRA is designed for property-level analysis.

Why does AllTheRooms charge per market?

AllTheRooms prices each geographic market separately. Their Basic plan at $19/mo covers one market. If you research multiple cities, you either pay for each one individually or upgrade to a State ($449/mo) or Country ($749/mo) plan. StaySTRA's Pro plan at $7/mo covers all 2,600+ US markets with no per-market fees.

Is AllTheRooms still being actively developed after the Deckard acquisition?

The consumer product remains available. However, Deckard Technologies is a GovTech company focused on municipal STR compliance. The long-term product roadmap for individual investors is uncertain. AllTheRooms' data and deduplication technology likely serves Deckard's compliance tools (Rentalscape) as much as the consumer analytics product.

Can I try both tools for free?

Yes. StaySTRA offers 3 free property analyses per month with no account required. AllTheRooms offers a free tier with 3 months of historical data and 5 competitor comparisons, but you must create an account.

Compare Other STR Tools

See how StaySTRA stacks up against other analyzers:

• StaySTRA vs AirDNA
• StaySTRA vs Mashvisor
• StaySTRA vs BNBCalc
• StaySTRA vs Rabbu
• StaySTRA vs Awning
• StaySTRA vs Airbtics
• StaySTRA vs Chalet
• StaySTRA vs STRInsights

View all comparisons →

Try StaySTRA Free

Run 3 free property analyses every month across 2,600+ US markets. See projected revenue, expenses, and 20+ investment metrics for any address. No account required, no credit card.

Analyze a Property Free →